Vegan Lentil Sweet Potato Pie

I discovered this recipe on a rainy autumn evening when my friend arrived at my door announcing she'd gone vegan, and I had exactly two hours to prove that plant-based comfort food could be just as satisfying as the traditional shepherds pie I grew up with. Standing in my kitchen, surrounded by sweet potatoes and lentils, I realized this wasn't just about feeding her—it was about showing her that the best meals come from genuine care, not compromise. That night, as we pulled the golden-topped dish from the oven, the kitchen filled with a smell so warm and inviting that any doubt melted away.

The first time I served this to my family's meat-loving skeptics, my dad went back for seconds and asked if I'd used actual cream cheese on top. When I told him it was pure sweet potato with a splash of plant milk, he went quiet for a moment, then admitted he preferred it to the original version his mother made. That moment—watching someone's assumptions crumble with a single bite—is exactly why I keep making this pie.

Ingredients

• Sweet potatoes: Buy firm ones without soft spots, as these mash to the silkiest consistency; I learned the hard way that watery potatoes lead to a runny topping.
• Brown or green lentils: They hold their shape during cooking, unlike red lentils which turn to mush—you want texture here.
• Olive oil: Use something you don't mind cooking with; the good stuff is wasted on high heat, so save your fancy oil for drizzling.
• Mushrooms: They add an umami depth that makes the filling taste savory and substantial, almost meaty.
• Smoked paprika: This is the secret weapon that gives the whole dish a subtle, smoky warmth that lingers.
• Plant-based milk: Oat or cashew milk works best; soy can make the mash slightly grainier.
• Soy sauce or tamari: Don't skip this—it's what transforms vegetables into real food.
• Fresh garlic: Always, always use fresh; jarred garlic makes everything taste like a dusty cupboard.

Instructions

Start with the sweet potatoes:

While your oven preheats, get those potatoes in boiling water so they'll be soft and ready by the time your filling is done. Chopping them into roughly equal sizes helps them cook at the same speed.

Build the savory base:

Heat oil in your skillet and let the onion and garlic cook until your kitchen smells irresistible—that's when you know they're ready. The garlic should be soft and fragrant, not brown.

Layer in the vegetables:

Add the harder vegetables first (carrots, celery) so they soften at the same rate as the softer ones. When everything is tender, the filling will feel almost silky.

Create depth with tomato paste:

Cook it for a full minute before adding liquid—this caramelizes it slightly and brings out a deeper flavor that transforms the whole filling.

Bring it all together:

Once you add the lentils and broth, you'll watch the mixture transform into something rich and glossy as it simmers. The peas go in at the very end so they stay bright green and tender.

Mash the topping:

Drain your sweet potatoes completely, then mash them while they're still warm—cold potatoes are stubborn and lumpy. The milk makes them spreadable and cloud-like.

Assemble and bake:

Spread the lentil mixture in your baking dish, then top with the mash, smoothing it gently with the back of a spoon. Bake until the top is set and golden.

Pin it

There's a specific moment, about halfway through baking, when the sweet potato top starts to set and golden edges appear. I always crack the oven door open and just breathe that in—it's the moment the dish becomes real, when you know you've made something beautiful. That's when I tell whoever's waiting in the living room that dinner is almost ready.

Why This Version Beats the Original

The beauty of a vegan shepherds pie is that nothing gets buried under heavy cream or butter—every vegetable tastes like itself, and the lentils provide protein without any of the guilt. The sweet potato topping is naturally sweet, so it creates this lovely contrast with the savory, herb-forward filling underneath. I've converted more than a few people who thought they couldn't eat vegan, simply by serving them this dish and letting the flavors speak for themselves.

Making It Your Own

This recipe is flexible enough to work with what you have on hand—if you don't have mushrooms, add more carrots; if celery isn't your thing, skip it without guilt. I've made this with finely chopped spinach stirred into the filling, and it adds both nutrition and a subtle earthiness that rounds everything out. The spices can shift too: a touch of cumin instead of rosemary gives it a warmer, different kind of comfort.

Serving and Storage

Shepherds pie is one of those dishes that improves with time, as the flavors continue to meld together overnight in the fridge. Serve it with something bright and crisp—a simple arugula salad or some steamed green beans cut through the richness beautifully. This keeps well for up to four days in the refrigerator, and reheats gently in a 180°C oven until warmed through, covered loosely with foil.

• A crack of fresh black pepper on top just before serving makes all the difference.
• If you're taking this to a potluck, assemble everything the night before and bake it fresh there if possible.
• Leftovers become an entirely different meal—crispy in a skillet for breakfast with some fresh greens on top.

Pin it

This pie has become my go-to dish for proof that vegan cooking isn't about deprivation—it's about discovering new ways to make people around your table feel cared for. Every time I make it, I'm reminded that the best recipes are the ones that bring people together.

Recipe FAQs

→ How can I make the mash creamier?

Add a splash of coconut milk or your preferred plant-based milk while mashing the sweet potatoes for extra creaminess.

→ Can I substitute the lentils with another protein?

Yes, cooked chickpeas or black beans can be used for a different texture and flavor while maintaining protein content.

→ What spices enhance the filling's flavor?

Thyme, rosemary, and smoked paprika create a savory and aromatic profile that complements the vegetables and lentils perfectly.

→ Is it possible to prepare this ahead of time?

The filling and mashed topping can be prepared in advance and assembled before baking, making it convenient for meal planning.

→ How can I add more greens to this dish?

Incorporate chopped spinach or kale into the lentil filling during cooking for added nutrition and color.